Scarlet BibleOpen in the app
Home

Catholic and Protestant: what’s the difference?

A gentle, honest look at where Catholics and Protestants agree, where they differ, and why it matters, with the Scripture behind each view.

Forgiveness

Once for all

Catholic teaching: Christ’s sacrifice is made present again in every Mass, and serious sins after baptism are forgiven through confession to a priest.

Protestant conviction: Jesus’ one sacrifice finished the work. “We have been sanctified through the offering of the body of Jesus Christ once for all” (Hebrews 10:10). “If we confess our sins, he is faithful and just to forgive us our sins” (1 John 1:9).

You can go straight to Jesus, today, for full forgiveness. Nothing needs to be added to what he has done.

Key passages: Hebrews 7:25–27; 9:24–28; 10:10–18 · Romans 8:1

Priests

Jesus, our great High Priest

Catholic teaching: Ordained priests act in the person of Christ, offer the Mass and pronounce absolution.

Protestant conviction: The Old Testament priesthood pointed to Jesus. Now “we have a great high priest… Jesus,” so we can “draw near to the throne of grace” ourselves (Hebrews 4:14–16). He “always lives to make intercession” for us (Hebrews 7:25). Every believer is part of “a royal priesthood” (1 Peter 2:9).

Pastors are gifts to shepherd and teach us. They aren’t needed to stand between you and God.

Salvation

Grace alone, through faith alone

Catholic teaching: Justification is a process that begins at baptism and grows through faith, the sacraments and good works, all enabled by grace.

Protestant conviction: God declares us righteous the moment we trust Christ, because his righteousness is credited to us. “By grace you have been saved through faith… not a result of works” (Ephesians 2:8–9; Romans 4:5).

Good works matter deeply. They are the fruit of being saved, not the root (Ephesians 2:10).

Mary

Blessed, but not our Savior

Every Christian should honor Mary. She said yes to God, and Scripture calls her blessed (Luke 1:48). But Mary herself called God “my Savior” (Luke 1:47). She needed a Savior too.

The Protestant conviction: “There is one mediator between God and men, the man Christ Jesus” (1 Timothy 2:5). We don’t need anyone else to bring our prayers to God (Hebrews 4:16).

None of the beliefs below are needed to know Jesus. He is enough.
When did these beliefs become official?
  1. AD 431
    “Mother of God” (Theotokos)Affirmed at Ephesus to protect the truth that Jesus is fully God. Protestants agree.
  2. 1400s
    “Co-Redemptrix” title appearsUsed by some, never made official doctrine.
  3. 1854
    Immaculate ConceptionThat Mary was conceived without sin. Defined about 1,800 years after Jesus.
  4. 1950
    AssumptionThat Mary was taken bodily into heaven. Defined about 1,900 years after Jesus.
  5. 2025
    Vatican: not “Co-Redemptrix”The Vatican said the title is not appropriate because it risks obscuring Christ’s unique role. We agree: Jesus alone saves.

Authority

Scripture as the final word

Catholic teaching: Scripture and Sacred Tradition together are God’s Word, interpreted with authority by the Magisterium (the pope and bishops).

Protestant conviction: Tradition can be a great help, but Scripture alone is the final, God-breathed authority that judges everything else (2 Timothy 3:16–17; Mark 7:8–13). The Bereans checked even the apostle Paul against Scripture (Acts 17:11).

When did these teachings become official?
  1. 1215
    TransubstantiationDefined at the Fourth Lateran Council.
  2. 1439
    PurgatoryFormally defined at the Council of Florence.
  3. 1546
    Tradition with Scripture; Apocrypha addedDeclared at the Council of Trent, in response to the Reformation.
  4. 1870
    Papal infallibilityDefined at the First Vatican Council.
The Scarlet Brief
One free email every Monday: a verse to carry, the thread to Jesus, a real archaeology find and a word to know. Get it free →