The Bible doesn’t really say what Christians think it says
“The Bible doesn’t really say what Christians think it says.” Brilliant people have said this. Here is someone who walked away, someone who came home, and what’s true.
Two people stood here
Says no: Dan McClellan
Biblical scholar and popular TikToker (a practicing Latter-day Saint, not an atheist).
“Frequently, the Bible does not say that.”
Where it was said: Salt Lake Tribune interview (2025)
Why we include this: His short videos reach millions, often telling viewers that traditional Christian readings are wrong. People are asking about it.
Came to faith: Rosaria Butterfield
Tenured English professor at Syracuse who read the Bible to critique Christians.
“I read the way a glutton devours.”
Where it was said: “My Train Wreck Conversion,” Christianity Today
Why we include this: She read the Bible to critique Christians, the way a scholar reads any text. Reading it whole, again and again, is what changed her.
Both are trained readers of texts. The difference: one reads the Bible in pieces to show what it doesn’t say; the other read it whole and found it says more than she expected, all of it pointing to Jesus.
Side by side
The objection: Christians read their own views into the Bible.
What’s true: Everyone brings assumptions. That’s why we read whole books in context, in the original languages, and let Scripture interpret Scripture.
The objection: The Bible contradicts itself, so it means whatever you want.
What’s true: Different voices aren’t contradictions. Many writers over 1,500 years tell one connected story that leads to Jesus (Luke 24:27).
The objection: Scholars have settled it: the traditional reading is wrong.
What’s true: Scholars disagree with each other. Many leading scholars, like Cambridge’s Peter J. Williams, read the Bible as Christians always have, using the same tools and data.
Source: Peter J. Williams, Can We Trust the Gospels? (Crossway)
Built on sand?
Jesus said a house built on sand falls when the storm comes, but a house built on rock stands (Matthew 7:24–27). Every view rests on a foundation, often an unspoken assumption. Here’s the assumption under this one, where it cracks, and how people came to see it.
The foundation: The Bible is a pile of separate pieces, so any verse can be pulled out and re-read.
Where it cracks: Read in pieces, any book can be made to say almost anything. Read whole, the Bible tells one connected story, and its big themes stay clear from Genesis to Revelation.
How people came to see it: Butterfield saw it by reading the whole Bible, again and again. That’s exactly what this site invites you to do.
Someone in the Bible like this
Nicodemus. Nicodemus was Israel’s respected teacher. He knew the texts, but Jesus said, “Are you the teacher of Israel and do not understand?” (John 3:10). Knowing a lot about the Bible isn’t the same as knowing its Author.
Sit with this
Am I reading the Bible to judge it, or letting it read me?
Go deeper with trusted Christian resources
- Review of The Bible Says So · The Gospel Coalition
- Can We Trust the Gospels? · Peter J. Williams, Cambridge · Crossway
He walks with you
On the road to Emmaus, two doubting followers were walking away, and “Jesus himself came near and walked with them” (Luke 24:15). He still does.
Explore more in the app ›Keep exploring
- A good God wouldn’t allow this much suffering
- Science has made God unnecessary. Faith is believing without evidence
- Jesus never claimed to be God. His followers made that up later
- The Bible was changed so many times, we can’t know what it originally said
One free email every Monday: a verse to carry, the thread to Jesus, a real archaeology find and a word to know. Get it free →