Scarlet BibleOpen in the app
Home › When Smart People Say No

A good God wouldn’t allow this much suffering

“A good God wouldn’t allow this much suffering.” Brilliant people have said this. Here is someone who walked away, someone who came home, and what’s true.

Two people stood here

Says no: Stephen Fry
British actor, writer and outspoken atheist. Asked on Irish TV what he would say to God, he answered with this.

“Bone cancer in children? What’s that about?”

Where it was said: The Meaning of Life, RTÉ (2015)

Why we include this: His words are blunt, but the pain behind them is honest. Many people feel exactly this. The Bible never tells you to hide it.

Came to faith: C. S. Lewis
Lost his mother to cancer when he was nine and became a committed atheist, partly because of suffering. Years later he described himself as…

“the most dejected and reluctant convert in all England.”

Where it was said: Surprised by Joy (on PBS)

Why we include this: Lewis knew the same anger at pain. He came to see that calling the world “unjust” only makes sense if there is a real standard of justice, which points to God.

Both men looked straight at suffering. One concluded God must be cruel or absent. The other found that suffering is exactly where Jesus meets us: God didn’t stay far away from pain; he took it on himself at the cross.

Side by side

The objection: If God were good and powerful, he’d stop suffering.

What’s true: He did more than stop it from a distance. In Jesus he stepped into it, and he promises to end it for good (Hebrews 4:15; Revelation 21:4).

The objection: The Bible gives contradictory answers about pain.

What’s true: It gives honest, layered ones: lament, testing, a broken world. And finally a Person, not a formula (Job 38–42; Romans 8:18–28).

The objection: Suffering proves no one is in charge.

What’s true: Calling suffering “wrong” assumes a real standard of good. That standard points to God, not away from him. C. S. Lewis made this exact argument after his years as an atheist.

Source: C. S. Lewis in his own words (PBS)

Built on sand?

Jesus said a house built on sand falls when the storm comes, but a house built on rock stands (Matthew 7:24–27). Every view rests on a foundation, often an unspoken assumption. Here’s the assumption under this one, where it cracks, and how people came to see it.

The foundation: If I can’t see a good reason for suffering, there must not be one.

Where it cracks: A God great enough to blame for suffering is great enough to have reasons we can’t see yet. And calling suffering “evil” needs a real standard of good and evil. Without God, suffering is just nature: painful, but not wrong.

How people came to see it: Lewis saw it when he realized his anger at an unjust world depended on the very idea of justice that points to God.

Someone in the Bible like this

Job. Job lost everything and demanded answers. God didn’t hand him an explanation. He gave him himself, and Job said, “Now my eyes have seen you” (Job 42:5).

Sit with this

Is my question about God’s logic, or about my pain? What if he has been near the whole time?

Go deeper with trusted Christian resources

He walks with you

On the road to Emmaus, two doubting followers were walking away, and “Jesus himself came near and walked with them” (Luke 24:15). He still does.

Explore more in the app ›

Keep exploring

The Scarlet Brief
One free email every Monday: a verse to carry, the thread to Jesus, a real archaeology find and a word to know. Get it free →