Jesus never claimed to be God. His followers made that up later
“Jesus never claimed to be God. His followers made that up later.” Brilliant people have said this. Here is someone who walked away, someone who came home, and what’s true.
Two people stood here
Says no: Bart Ehrman
Professor at UNC Chapel Hill. Former evangelical, now agnostic.
“Jesus himself didn’t call himself God and didn’t consider himself God.”
Where it was said: NPR, Fresh Air interview (2014)
Why we include this: Ehrman is one of the most widely read critics, so many people meet this idea through him. It deserves a real answer.
Came to faith: Lee Strobel
Atheist legal editor at the Chicago Tribune who set out to disprove the resurrection.
“I thought I could disprove the resurrection over a weekend.”
Where it was said: Q&A, Billy Graham Library
Why we include this: Strobel investigated as a skeptical journalist, interviewing scholars and checking the sources. The evidence for the resurrection changed his mind.
The question isn’t only what Jesus said about himself, but what happened next. If he rose from the dead, his claims stand. That’s why Strobel’s investigation centered on the empty tomb.
Side by side
The objection: Belief in Jesus as God developed slowly, much later.
What’s true: Within about 20 years of the cross, Paul’s letters already worship Jesus as Lord alongside the Father (1 Corinthians 8:6; Philippians 2:6–11). Even Ehrman says the very first Christians believed God had raised Jesus and made him divine.
Source: Ehrman on NPR, Fresh Air (2014)
The objection: Only John’s late Gospel makes Jesus divine.
What’s true: Even in Mark, the earliest Gospel, Jesus forgives sins as only God can (Mark 2:5–7) and claims God’s own throne (Mark 14:62).
The objection: Ancient people made gods out of great men all the time.
What’s true: Not faithful Jews. They would die before worshiping anyone but God. Scholar Larry Hurtado showed that worship of Jesus burst out among Jewish believers in the first years, not slowly over centuries.
Source: Larry Hurtado, University of Edinburgh (Bible and Interpretation)
Built on sand?
Jesus said a house built on sand falls when the storm comes, but a house built on rock stands (Matthew 7:24–27). Every view rests on a foundation, often an unspoken assumption. Here’s the assumption under this one, where it cracks, and how people came to see it.
The foundation: The Gospels were changed over a long time, so the real Jesus must have been only a man.
Where it cracks: Our earliest Christian writings, Paul’s letters from about 20 years after the cross, already worship Jesus as Lord. That’s too fast for a legend to grow. And the empty tomb still needs an explanation.
How people came to see it: Strobel saw it when he tried to explain the resurrection away and found the evidence kept holding.
Someone in the Bible like this
Thomas. Thomas wouldn’t believe without evidence. Jesus didn’t scold him; he showed him his wounds. Thomas answered, “My Lord and my God!” (John 20:28).
Sit with this
If Jesus really rose from the dead, what would that change for me?
Go deeper with trusted Christian resources
- How God Became Jesus · Five New Testament scholars respond · Zondervan
- The Case for Christ · Lee Strobel · Zondervan
He walks with you
On the road to Emmaus, two doubting followers were walking away, and “Jesus himself came near and walked with them” (Luke 24:15). He still does.
Explore more in the app ›Keep exploring
- A good God wouldn’t allow this much suffering
- Science has made God unnecessary. Faith is believing without evidence
- The Bible doesn’t really say what Christians think it says
- The Bible was changed so many times, we can’t know what it originally said
One free email every Monday: a verse to carry, the thread to Jesus, a real archaeology find and a word to know. Get it free →